A journey through India’s affordable housing Part 2: to the outskirts of Mumbai

Microfinance Focus, 25 November 2012, Co-authored with Vikash Kumar
 
This article is part of a series aimed at understanding what’s happening in India’s affordable housing sector.  It is based on interviews with residents of three low-cost housing projects:  Vaishnavi Sai (outside Mumbai), Anandgram (outside Pune), and Janaadhar Shubha (outside Bangalore).   The interviews were conducted during May-June 2012.  Read Part 1 here.

After a long train ride – nearly two hours – the line ends.  Passengers disembark at a small, but bustling community, easily covered on foot.  The commerce around the station is busy, but within a few city blocks, one already spies farmland beyond the last rows of houses.  Residents of all stripes live here, but the feel is decidedly working-class.

This could easily be late 19th century streetcar suburb outside Chicago or New York.  Or a fin-de-siècle banlieue on the outskirts of Paris.  But no, it’s Virar, one of the terminal stops on the Western Railways line heading north out of Mumbai.  Read full article here.

Journey through India’s affordable housing Part I: Introduction

Microfinance Focus, 16 October 2012, Co-authored with Vikash Kumar

This article is part of a series aimed at understanding what’s happening in India’s affordable housing sector.  It is based on interviews with residents of three low-cost housing projects:  Vaishnavi Sai (outside Mumbai), Anandgram (outside Pune), and Janaadhar Shubha (outside Bangalore).   The interviews were conducted during May-June 2012. Read Part 2 here.

Something is afoot in the low cost housing market in India.  Over the last two years, dozens of commercially-built projects targeted at the lower middle class have been going up in cities across the country, with tens, if not hundreds, of thousands of units being built.  In the past six months, many of these projects have begun opening their doors to the new residents.  We decided to pay some of them a visit. more →

Beyond the Microenterprise: the Case for Housing Loans

European Microfinance Platform, August 2012 Newsletter

Allow me an impertinent question, dear reader:  what was the largest loan you ever borrowed?  Now, let me venture a guess – was it your home mortgage?  If you answered no, then you probably fit either of three profiles:  1) you never had to buy a home, 2) you live in a country with limited financial access, or 3) you are very lucky.

Let’s set luck aside for the moment.  Why the first two assumptions?  Because in developed countries, mortgage finance takes by far the largest share of consumer credit.  In the US, mortgages on residential property account for 84% of average household debt.  In the UK, the number is 89%.  There is no question that the primary goal of retail lending in rich countries is to fund housing.  Now consider the numbers for housing loans in the microfinance sector.

They are depressingly small.  more →

What’s wrong and what’s right about consumer finance?

Financial Access Initiative, 8 May 2012

It’s the microfinance bête noire.  The great unspeakable.  The furtive shadow slinking down the narrow alleys of poverty.  Yes, the consumer loan.  Has microfinance really come to this, we ask?  Helping the poor buy a TV?  Charging 40% interest for the couch to go in front of that TV?  And what about family celebrations, festivals, dowries?  Is that really what microcredit is for?

Consumption lending has been creeping out from the shadows for some time, but mostly for “good” consumption like school fees, urgent medical care, or basic needs like food during those difficult periods when income is scarce.  Still, for many of us the TV-on-credit notion that represents what is so easy to think of as “bad” consumption remains too painful an idea to swallow.

But how to draw the line?  If not the TV, then what about a microwave?  A motorbike?  Plumbing in the home?  Is there a framework one can use to evaluate when consumer credit is acceptable and when it is not?  No less importantly, how does an institution dedicated to serving poor customers decide what type of funding mechanism – savings or credit – is more appropriate for a given purpose?  more →

Microfinance without the MFI? Zidisha tests the boundaries of microlending methodology

Financial Access Initiative, 5 July 2011

What does a microlending operation look like?  Well, it may be a bank or an NGO (and many others in between), it probably has some branches, branch managers, loan officers.  The funding of the MFI may come from deposits or from debt, whether from a local or foreign institution, including from online platforms such as Kiva.  There may be variations on these themes, but that pretty much describes microlending as we know it.

What if you took all that away – the branches, the loan officers, the institutional funders?  Could the lending still work?  Well, one model is that of Zidisha Microfinance, an online lending platform that connects lenders in (mostly) developed countries with borrowers in developing ones.  And, unlike Kiva, the connections are real – borrowers create their own online profiles, post their own loan applications, and make their own repayments.  They also post their own comments, as do the lenders.  There is no local MFI intermediary – it is literally the first true person-to-person (P2P) microfinance lending platform in the world. more →